Flavors & Pricing
Underneath the icing lies some amazing flavors
We offer a large number of flavors and fillings that can be added to your cake. When consulting with us,
just ask about these flavors and fillings and whether or not they can be incorporated.
Custom Wedding Cake Flavors & Pricing in Atlanta, GA
At Frosted Pumpkin Wedding Cakes, we believe your wedding cake should taste every bit as incredible as it looks. Serving Atlanta, GA, and surrounding areas, we create custom wedding cakes that combine artistic design with carefully selected cake flavors, fillings, and icings. Whether your vision is timeless and elegant or completely one-of-a-kind, we'll help you find a combination that complements your celebration.
Find the Perfect Wedding Cake Flavor
Choosing your cake is one of the sweetest parts of planning your wedding. Frosted Pumpkin offers an extensive selection of flavors that can be paired with mousses, creams, ganache, caramel, and other fillings to create a cake your guests will remember.
Popular options include:
- Cake Flavors: Chocolate, Vanilla Genoise, French Vanilla, Red Velvet, Almond, Lemon, Marble, and Carrot
- Icing Options: Swiss Butter Cream, Fudge, and Rolled Fondant
- Mousse Fillings: Chocolate, Raspberry, Strawberry, Mocha, Vanilla, Lemon, Hazelnut, Almond, White Chocolate, Key Lime, and Cappuccino
- Specialty Fillings: Dark Chocolate Ganache, Cream Cheese, Salted Caramel, Coconut Creme, German Chocolate, Lemon Zest Cream Cheese, and Cannoli
Some specialty flavors and options may include an additional charge.
Wedding Cake Pricing
Wedding cake pricing depends on the number of guests, tiers, design, icing, and decorative details. Current general pricing for Classic Cake designs includes 3-tier cakes serving up to 120 guests starting at $850, 4-tier cakes serving up to 150 guests at $1,050, and 4-tier cakes serving up to 180 guests at $1,250. These cakes are iced with Frosted Pumpkin's Swiss Butter Cream, while Signature Cake designs are individually priced.
Taste, Design & Create Your Perfect Cake
Not sure which flavors belong on your wedding menu? Explore our Cake Gallery for design inspiration or schedule a private consultation or sample plate pickup to experience different flavor combinations before making your selection. Together, we'll create a custom wedding cake that reflects your style and gives your Atlanta-area celebration a memorable finishing touch.
The Right Flavors Make the Cake
Cake Flavors
- Chocolate
- Vanilla Genoise
- French Vanilla
- Red Velvet
- Almond
- Lemon
- Marble
- Carrot*
Icing Flavors
- Swiss Butter Cream
- Fudge
- Rolled Fondant*
Mousse Fillings
- Chocolate
- Raspberry
- Strawberry
- Mocha
- Vanilla
- Lemon
- Hazelnut
- Almond
- White Chocolate
- Cappuccino
Other Fillings
- (NEW!) Lemon Cake filled with Lemon Cream Cheese and House-made Organic Blueberry preserves
- Dark Chocolate Ganache
- Cream Cheese
- Salted Caramel
- Coconut Creme
- German Chocolate
- Lemon Zest Cream Cheese
- Cannoli*
*Flavors marked with an asterisk add an additional charge. But they are totally worth it.
General Pricing Information
To warmly assist you, we're delighted to share some general pricing information from The Frosted Pumpkin Wedding Cakes
Wedding Cakes
| Tiers | Feeds up to | Price |
| 3 Tiers | 120 people | $850.00 |
| 4 Tiers | 150 people | $1,050.00 |
| 4 Tiers | 180 people | $1,250.00 |
These cakes are iced with our amazing Swiss Butter Cream. Pricing is based on designs on our Classic Cakes Gallery. Any fresh flowers would be supplied and placed by your floral designer. We also offer rolled fondant and gum paste sugar designs.
Prices for designs on our Signature Cakes Gallery vary, please call or email to discuss with us.
Special Occassion Cakes
Your special occasion deserves nothing less than the exceptional, and we are here to ensure every detail is a sweet reflection of your unique celebration.
Our single tier cakes start at $125.00 and feed approximately 25 people.
We would love to help you create an amazing special occasion so please call or email us for more information.
Why Choose Us?
- We believe our cakes should be presented the best way possible. Wedding cakes need to be placed on a board for transport, we use custom ordered wooden boards specific to the size need and hand paint them to match the color of the icing being used. This seemingly small detail makes a big difference in the overall look of the cake.
- We use Premium European butter that brings a creamy texture and elegant presentation, elevating our creations to unmatched levels of quality and indulgence.
- We make our own vanilla extract using vanilla beans from Madagascar (these are the best in the world) soaked in 100% bourbon for a minimum of 18 months to achieve its full flavor.
Private Consultations
Private consultations are charged at $75 when ordering wedding cakes that serve 100 or more people.